English

Live Chat

Product

Test Library

Pricing

Use Cases

Resources

Home

Pricing

The Recruiter's Guide to On-Demand Video Interviews

- by Anonymous

August 18, 2025

You have a new role open. You post the job, and within a few days, your inbox is overflowing. A hundred, maybe two hundred, applications to sift through. Each one is a wall of text. You start scheduling phone screens, and suddenly your calendar is a chaotic mess of 15-minute slots that stretch over two weeks.

You spend hours talking to people who look great on paper but can’t string a sentence together. Or they’re just not a fit. By the time you’ve narrowed it down to a handful of good candidates, you’re exhausted, and the hiring manager is getting impatient.

Sound familiar?

This is the reality for a lot of us in hiring. The initial screening phase can feel like a huge time sink. That’s why so many teams are looking at tools to make it better. One of those tools is the on-demand, or one-way, video interview.

If you’ve been hesitant to try them, I get it. They can seem impersonal, or just another piece of tech to learn. But when you use them the right way, they can seriously help you get your time back and focus on what really matters: talking to great candidates.

This guide will walk you through it. No buzzwords, no promises to "revolutionize your hiring." Just a straightforward look at what these interviews are, how to use them well, and how to do it without creating a terrible experience for your candidates.

First Off, What Are We Actually Talking About?

An on-demand video interview isn't a Zoom call. There's no live conversation.

Here's the simple breakdown:

You write the questions ahead of time.
You send a special link to your candidates.
Candidates open the link on their own time, see your questions one by one, and record their answers using their camera.
You get a notification when they're done. You can watch their answers whenever you want.

Think of it as a structured, video-based replacement for the initial phone screen. It’s a way to get a little more information than a resume gives you, before you commit to a live conversation. You get to hear them talk through their experience and get a basic sense of their communication style, all without the back-and-forth of scheduling.

It’s a simple concept, but the details matter. For a more detailed look at the mechanics, our post on One-Way Video Interviews: Everything You Need to Know is a good place to start.

So, Why Should You Bother? The Real Payoff

Let's skip the marketing pitch and talk about the actual, practical reasons why this might be a good idea for your team.

1. You Will Save a Ton of Time. This is the big one. Think about the time it takes to screen 20 candidates by phone. You have to email back and forth to find a time, you have the pre-call small talk, the actual call, and then you write up your notes. That's easily 20-30 minutes per person. For 20 candidates, you’ve lost a full day or more.

With one-way video interviews, you send out 20 links at once. The responses roll in over the next few days. You can sit down and review them all in one batch. You can watch them at 1.5x speed. You can skip a rambling answer. That full day of phone screens can be condensed into just a couple of hours. This isn’t about being lazy; it’s about being efficient so you can spend your time on the later, more important interview stages.

2. It Makes Things Fairer. When you're on a live phone screen, the conversation can wander. A candidate you click with might get more time or different questions than one you don't. It’s not intentional, but it happens.

One-way interviews create a more controlled environment for the first screening. Every single candidate gets the exact same questions, in the same order, with the same amount of time to answer. This gives you a much better apples-to-apples comparison. You’re evaluating everyone on the same criteria, which is a solid step toward reducing bias in your process.

3. It’s Flexible for Everybody. Your schedule is packed. So is your candidate's. They might have a job they can't easily step away from. They might have kids. They might be in a completely different time zone.

Asking them to record an interview on their own schedule is respectful of their time. They can do it at night after the kids are in bed, or on a weekend. And for you and your hiring managers, it means you can review responses first thing in the morning with coffee, or in a quiet hour at the end of the day. No more scheduling headaches.

4. You Can See Communication Skills in Action. A resume can’t show you if someone can explain a complex idea clearly. It can’t show you if they sound engaged and thoughtful. A one-way video interview can. You get an early look at how they structure their thoughts and present themselves. This is incredibly valuable for roles that are client-facing, require a lot of presentations, or involve close team collaboration.

5. Sharing with the Team is Easy. Ever had a great phone screen, and then tried to explain to the hiring manager why the candidate was so good? It’s hard to translate that feeling. With a recorded interview, you don’t have to. You can just share the link to a specific answer and say, "Watch this." It makes it much easier to get the team aligned on who to move forward with, and it saves you from having to schedule yet another meeting.

Setting It Up for Success (Without Being Annoying)

The difference between a helpful screening tool and a frustrating candidate experience is all in the setup. If you're thoughtful here, you'll get better responses and leave a good impression.

Choosing Your Platform

There are a lot of tools out there for this. When you're looking around, don't get distracted by a million flashy features. Focus on the basics:

Is it easy for candidates? If a candidate has to download software or fight with a clunky interface, they're going to start the process already frustrated. Look for a simple, web-based platform.
Is it easy for you? How hard is it to create an interview and send it out? Can you easily review and share responses? You're doing this to save time, so the tool shouldn't be complicated.
Can you customize it? You should be able to add your company logo and write a welcome message. This makes the experience feel less robotic.

Of course, we built TestTrick’s one-way video interview software to be straightforward and user-friendly for exactly these reasons. But it's smart to look at what's out there. To help with that, we've put together a list of the Top 7 One-Way Video Interview Software for Smarter Hiring. And if you're trying to weigh specific options, seeing a direct comparison like our breakdown of TestTrick Alternatives: Hireflix vs SparkHire can also be really helpful.

Crafting Good Questions

This is maybe the most important part. Your questions determine the quality of the answers you get.

Keep it short. A screening is not a deep-dive interview. Three to five questions is perfect. Any more than that, and you're asking for too much of a candidate's time for an initial step.

Focus on "Tell me about a time when..." These are behavioral questions, and they get you much better information than hypotheticals. Instead of asking "How do you handle conflict?", ask "Tell me about a time you disagreed with a coworker. What was the situation, and how did you resolve it?"

Mix it up. A good structure is:

1. An opener: Something like "Walk me through your resume and tell me what led you to apply for this role." It's familiar and helps them warm up.

2. Two role-specific questions: Look at the top two requirements in the job description. Craft a behavioral question for each. (e.g., For a project manager: "Tell me about a complex project you managed. What was your process for keeping it on track?")

3. A motivation question: "What specifically about this role and our company caught your interest?" This shows you who has done their homework.

What to avoid:

Brain teasers: "How many golf balls fit in a school bus?" These don't tell you anything useful and just stress people out.
Yes/No questions: You want them to talk, so make your questions open-ended.
Vague questions: "What are your strengths?" is okay, but "What's one skill you have that isn't on your resume but would be valuable in this role?" is more interesting.

Writing the Invitation Email

The email you send to invite candidates is their first interaction with this process. Make it a good one. Be clear, be human, and be transparent.

Here's a simple checklist of what to include:

A friendly opening: Thank them for applying.
Explain what it is: "As a next step, we'd like to invite you to a brief one-way video interview."
Explain why you use it: Be honest. "This helps us get to know more candidates and gives you the flexibility to complete it whenever works best for you."
Set expectations: Tell them how many questions there are and roughly how long it will take (e.g., "There are 4 questions, and it should take about 15 minutes to complete.").
Give a clear deadline: Be reasonable. A 24-hour deadline is stressful. Give them at least 3-5 days.
Provide simple instructions: "Just click the link below to get started. You'll have a chance to test your camera and mic first."
Offer help: "If you run into any technical issues, please reply to this email."
The link: Don't forget the actual link to the interview.

A little bit of transparency goes a long way in making candidates feel respected.

Reviewing the Answers: How to Spot What Matters

You have a dashboard full of completed interviews. Now you need to review them efficiently without letting your own biases get in the way.

1. Build a Simple Scorecard. Before you watch the first video, decide on the 3-4 things you're actually looking for. Don't just go on a gut feeling. Your criteria might be:

Clarity of Communication: Did they answer the question directly? Was their story easy to follow?
Relevant Experience: Did the examples they gave actually relate to the job requirements?
Problem-Solving: When asked about a challenge, did they show a logical approach?
Enthusiasm: Did they seem genuinely interested in the role and the company?

Rate each candidate on these points on a simple 1-3 scale. This keeps you focused and makes your evaluations much more consistent.

2. Look for Substance, Not Polish. This isn't a public speaking contest. Candidates are going to be nervous. They might say "um" or look away from the camera. That's fine. Don't mistake nervousness for a lack of competence.

Instead, focus on the content of their answers. Did they use the STAR method (Situation, Task, Action, Result) to give a complete example? Did they provide specific details instead of vague statements? A slightly nervous candidate with a great, detailed story is much better than a super-smooth talker who doesn't actually say anything.

3. Actively Check for Bias. This is really important. A video introduces a lot of information that a resume doesn't: what someone looks like, what their home looks like, their accent. Our brains are wired to make snap judgments based on this stuff.

Be conscious of it. That scorecard you made is your best tool to fight it. Force yourself to evaluate candidates based on the pre-defined criteria, not on whether you liked their bookshelf or thought they were "personable." A structured process is the best way to make your hiring more inclusive.

The Candidate Experience Is Everything

One-way video interviews get a bad rap sometimes, and it’s usually because they were implemented poorly. A bad process can make candidates feel like they’re just another number and can even damage your employer brand.

Here’s how to do it right:

Be Human in Your Communication: As mentioned before, a friendly, transparent invitation sets the right tone. Avoid cold, robotic language.
Don't Make It a Surprise: Some companies spring a video interview on a candidate immediately after they hit "submit" on an application. This is a bad idea. Let it be a separate, distinct step that they can prepare for.
Keep It Brief and Relevant: Your questions should be directly related to the job. This is a screening step; you're not asking for a huge time investment.
Provide a Way Out: For candidates who may not have access to the right tech or have a disability that makes a video interview difficult, offer an alternative, like a phone call. It’s the right thing to do.
Close the Loop. Always. This is the biggest rule. If someone takes the time to record a video for you, you owe them a response. Even if it's a "no," send them an email. Ghosting a candidate after they’ve put themselves on camera for you is a guaranteed way to get a bad review on Glassdoor.

Getting this right isn't complicated. It just means remembering there’s a person on the other side of the screen.

Where This Fits in Your Hiring Process

A one-way video interview isn't a replacement for your entire hiring process. It's a tool for a specific job: top-of-funnel screening.

It works best when it replaces the initial phone screen. A good, modern hiring workflow might look something like this:

1. Application: The candidate applies.

2. One-Way Video Interview: You send this to all qualified applicants to get a better sense of their experience and communication skills.

3. Skills Assessment: For the top candidates from the video screen, you send a short, practical test that's relevant to the job (like a coding challenge for a developer or a writing test for a marketer).

4. Live Interview: Now you're finally spending your valuable time on a live conversation with a small group of highly qualified candidates who you know have the right skills.

5. Final Round / Offer: You bring in the finalists to meet the team.

By structuring it this way, each step gives you more specific information. You're not just relying on how well someone talks; you're looking at their communication skills, their practical skills, and then their team fit. It's a more complete picture.

Platforms like TestTrick are designed to help you build out this kind of structured process, combining video interviews with skills assessments to give you better hiring data.

To Sum It Up

On-demand video interviews are just a tool. They aren’t magic. They won't automatically find you the perfect hire.

But they can be a very practical way to make the first step of your hiring process more efficient and a lot fairer. They can free you up from the endless grind of scheduling phone screens so you can focus on building relationships with your best candidates.

The key is to be thoughtful. Choose a simple platform, write good questions, and above all, treat your candidates with respect. If you do that, you'll find that one-way video interviews can be a genuinely helpful part of your recruiting toolkit.

One-Way Video Interviews : Everything You Need to Know

Hireflix vs SparkHire: Which One-Way Video Interview Software Wins? (Spoiler: It's TestTrick)

Latest posts